Milk and Sugar Cafe

Hours: Monday-Friday 9am -10pm
Sunday 9am-1pm

[04/13/17] Join us for Easter Brunch!!
Unlimited Mimosas, Bloody Mary's, Coffee, Tea and Soda.
Omelet & Carving Station!
French Toast, Waffles, Bacon & Sausage
Assorted Salads, Sandwiches, Wraps and so so much more!!
Call And Make A Reservation

[12/29/16] Happy New Year 2017
Join us for New Year's Day brunch on Sunday
From 9-3 pm.
Kids eat for free 3-10 years of age
Reservations for parties of 6 or more.
First 10 tables receive a $20 gift card.
Certain restrictions apply.

[05/05/16] Please don't forget your MOM this Mother's Day and take her to our Mothers Day brunch
Adults are $39.95 and kids are $14.95

Please call to make your reservations


[02/03/16] Milk and sugar cafe
Valentine's Day brunch from 9-3 pm
39.95 per person. Bloody Mary's, mimosa, carving station, entrees, and much much more.
We are accepting Dinner reservations for valentines night
Dinner specials and cocktails.
Please call to make your reservations early.
Thank you
Milk and sugar cafe.

[03/25/15] Easter Sunday Brunch at Milk and Sugar Cafe is April 5, 2015!

We are now accepting reservations for our annual Easter Brunch from 9am-3pm
$29.95 for adults, $12.95 for kids 3-10yrs.

Includes: Mimosas, Bloody Marys, Carving station, omelet station, continental breakfast, entrees, salads, and much much more.

Please call to reserve your table now. 631-969-3655

PS...Easter Bunny will be making his appearance!

[04/23/14] Reservations a must for this Friday's Comedy Night! Tickets are selling out.

Three Course Dinner followed by a Comedy Show. Starts at 7pm.
Tickets are $49.95 plus tax and gratuity.


[04/15/14] 10 Days left to book your reservations for Comedy Night at the Victorian Room!

April 25th we are having a Three Course Dinner followed by a Comedy Show. Tickets are 49.95 plus tax & grat. Please call 631-969-3655 for reservations. Dinner at 7pm, show at 9pm.

[04/15/14] Pasta Night Tonite!

Three Course Dinner for $14.95.
1st- Anti Pasta Salad

2nd- Choice:
~Gemmelli Pasta Tossed with Fried Eggplant, Fres Mozzarella, topped with Riccotta
~Whole Wheat Penne with Roasted Garlic & Sundried Tomato Cream Sauce and Spinach
~Bucattini with White Clam Sauce
~Penne Pasta with Cherry Pepper Vodka & Grilled Chicken

3rd-Dessert...Chef Du Jour

[04/09/14] Comedy Night is fast approaching! Book your reservations today!

[04/02/14] Taking Reservations now for Easter Day Brunch.
$29.95 9am to 3pm
Seating available at 9am, 10:30am, 12pm, 1:30pm, and 3pm.

Our Fabulous Easter Sunday Brunch will include:
-Omelet Station
-Carving Station
-Pasta Station
-Bloody Mary's and Mimosas
-Hot Entree Dishes from breakfast and lunch items.
-Fresh Salad and Fruit Display
-Assortment of Bagels and pastries.

Please call for reservations. 631.969.3655



Price Range




49 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 10pm
Tuesday 9am - 10pm
Wednesday 9am - 10pm
Thursday 9am - 10pm
Friday 9am - 10pm
Saturday 9am - 10pm
Other New American Restaurants in Bay Shore (show all)
The LakeHouse The LakeHouse
135 Maple Ave
Bay Shore, 11706-8320

TGI Fridays TGI Fridays
1725 Sunrise Highway
Bay Shore, 11706

Salt & Barrel Salt & Barrel
61 W Main St
Bay Shore, 11706

An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe & vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps & coastal fare with a rotating selection of oysters daily